Skip to content
DoctorMixAlot.
Menu

Alphonso Davies' Hamstring: Why a Clean MRI Meant Nothing

Davies' MRI came back clean, then his hamstring tore 5 minutes into Canada vs. Guatemala. Doc, a PharmD, explains what a scan can't see.

By Doc, PharmD, CSN2 min read

Watch on YouTube

Alphonso Davies’ MRI came back clean. But his hamstring warned him a week before it tore playing for Canada.

What happened to Alphonso Davies?

In Bayern’s last game before the international break, against Mainz, Davies mentioned feeling something in the back of his thigh.

When he got to Canada, he was scanned before the Mexico match. The MRI came back clean. Nothing there. He said he felt 100%.

Then, 5 minutes into the game against Guatemala, he had to come off. It looked like he slipped a little, took a twist, and that was it. Another hamstring injury.

It’s one more blow to a Bayern squad that’s already stretched thin. I wrote about that in my Quick Take on why Bayern need rotation players in January.

Can an MRI tell if a player is ready?

No. And this is my issue with leaning on scans.

An MRI is great at one thing: showing damage. If there’s a tear, it’ll find it. But it doesn’t tell you if a player is ready. Here’s what it can’t see:

  • Fatigue. A tired muscle looks the same on a scan as a fresh one.
  • Strength. It can’t tell you if the muscles around the hamstring are strong enough to protect it.
  • Timing. Muscles have to fire at the right moment. A scan is a still picture, so you can’t see if the hamstring is firing on time.

So “clean MRI” really means “no damage yet.” That’s not the same as “good to go.”

Why does Davies keep getting hamstring injuries?

The number one reason a hamstring tears is that it’s torn before. Davies has been here already.

And this comes after a complete knee rebuild from his ACL injury. When a knee has been through that, the hamstring works overtime to help protect it. More work means more load, and more load means more risk.

This is the same thing that happened at the World Cup: a clean MRI, then a small hamstring injury.

What should Bayern and Canada do?

Listen to the player.

If I’m Alphonso Davies and something feels off, I’m not playing. Period. He knows what it feels like right before it happens better than any scan does.

And Davies has said what scares him the most: surgery. If this keeps happening, it gets worse and worse until surgery is the only option. Nobody wants that, for him or for Bayern.

Should Canada have played him? Let me know what you think.

Doc, PharmD, CSN

Written by

Doc, PharmD, CSN

Pharmacist, sports nutritionist, soccer obsessive. Doc breaks down the game with the eye of someone trained to read the evidence.

Free weekly newsletter

Doc's weekly prescription.

The week's best takes from Doc, PharmD, in one email. Once a week. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.