Klopp's Germany 5-0 Netherlands: The Rule He Broke That Nagelsmann Never Would
Germany smashed the Netherlands 5-0 in Berlin to top their Nations League group. Doc breaks down the one rule Klopp broke, and whether it's a real fix.
By Doc, PharmD, CSN3 min read
Germany just smashed the Netherlands 5-0 in Berlin. And the reason is simple. Jürgen Klopp broke the one rule Julian Nagelsmann refused to break.
Nagelsmann’s rule was this: big names keep their spot. Klopp looked at that and said, nah, bro.
What happened in Germany vs. Netherlands?
Germany beat the Netherlands 5-0 at the Olympiastadion on November 16. The game was in the Nations League, and Germany needed to win by at least five goals to top the group. They got exactly five. That sent them into the quarterfinals, ahead of the Dutch on goal difference.
Here’s how the goals went, per Yahoo Sports:
- 41’ Derry Scherhant, set up by Joshua Kimmich
- 60’ Florian Wirtz, a curler from 25 yards
- 65’ Nico Schlotterbeck, a header off a Brajan Gruda free kick
- 71’ Wirtz again, off a Gruda cutback
- 78’ Gruda, off the rebound after Scherhant hit the post
What rule did Klopp break?
Under Nagelsmann, if you had a big name, your spot was safe. Under Klopp, every single position has to be earned.
Here’s the proof. For his first window, Klopp called up 44 players, split into two groups for four games. 16 of those 44 had never played for Germany. And Leroy Sané and Leon Goretzka? Left out.
That’s a statement. Those are two guys Nagelsmann kept going back to.
Why did Nagelsmann’s way fail?
Look at the World Cup. Nagelsmann had said Sané would need a great season in Türkiye to make the squad. Sané had a poor one, and he still kept his spot. Goretzka was on the plane too, even though his role was never clear, according to this breakdown.
Then came Paraguay in the round of 32 on June 29. The game finished 1-1 after extra time. In the shootout, things got chaotic, and Jonathan Tah missed Germany’s sixth kick. Paraguay won it 4-3 on penalties, per Fox Sports. CNN noted it was the first time Germany ever lost a World Cup shootout.
Klopp saw all that and went for the easy fix: earn your shirt.
Who stood out against the Netherlands?
The new guys, and that’s the whole point.
Derry Scherhant. A Berlin kid scoring Germany’s first goal in Berlin. And it wasn’t a tap-in. He smashed it into the far top corner. It was his first goal for Germany.
Brajan Gruda. One goal and two assists. This kid was everywhere. I hope Bayern Munich are paying attention to this lad.
Florian Wirtz. Even the star of the team was eating. Two goals, and the first one was a beauty.
Is Klopp’s Germany a real fix or a honeymoon?
Here’s my honest take. This works in November. Hungry players with something to prove will run through a wall for a coach in his first window.
But the Nations League isn’t a tournament. What happens at the next Euros, when the game gets tight and you need leaders on the pitch? Guys who have been there before? That’s when we find out if “earn your spot” is a real fix or just good vibes.
For now, I’m buying it. A coach who picks on form, not on name, is exactly what Germany needed after Paraguay.
So what do you think: is Klopp the real deal, or is this just the honeymoon? Send this to a friend who thinks Klopp is just vibes.
Sources
- Yahoo Sports: Germany 5-0 Netherlands, Wirtz brace inspires five-goal rout
- Bundesliga.com: Germany into Nations League quarter-finals with Netherlands rout
- ESPN: Germany 5-0 Netherlands (Nov 16, 2026)
- Sports Mole: Klopp's 44-man Germany squad including 16 uncapped players
- Fox Sports: Paraguay knocks Germany out of 2026 World Cup after penalty shootout
- CNN: Paraguay shocks Germany in the World Cup round of 32
- Tactical Football Analysis: Nagelsmann's failure and Klopp's rebuild

Free weekly newsletter
Doc's weekly prescription.
The week's best takes from Doc, PharmD, in one email. Once a week. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
More from Doc
Bayern Munich Need Rotation Players in January. Waiting Is a Mistake
By Doc, PharmD, CSN2 min read
Bayern Munich Transfer Targets: Tresoldi Yes, Prestianni No
By Doc, PharmD, CSN▶ 1:12 video
Alphonso Davies' Hamstring: Why a Clean MRI Meant Nothing
By Doc, PharmD, CSN▶ 1:12 video