Skip to content
DoctorMixAlot.
Menu

Manuel Neuer's Tendon Tear Isn't Bad Luck. A PharmD Explains Why

Neuer suffered a partial tendon tear in his right foot against Mainz. Doc, a PharmD, explains why tendons heal slowly, why age makes it worse, and what's next.

By Doc, PharmD, CSN2 min read

Watch on YouTube

Manuel Neuer’s foot injury is not bad luck. At 40, it’s biology. And biology only goes one way.

What happened to Manuel Neuer?

Neuer had to come off in Bayern’s 2-1 win at Mainz on November 7. The next day, Bayern confirmed a partial tendon tear in his right foot, per Bundesliga.com.

Here’s the part that worries me. It’s the same foot that already kept him out earlier this season with tendon irritation. He had just missed two league games with that foot before Mainz, per Reuters.

How long will Neuer be out?

Bayern haven’t given a timeline. They only said he’s out “for the time being.”

In my experience, a partial tendon tear like this is at least two months. German media are in the same range: Bild reported about two months, and Sky reported at least six weeks, with no return expected in 2026. Those are reports, not official.

Why do tendons heal so slowly?

This is where you have to know the difference between a muscle and a tendon.

Muscles have tons of blood vessels running through them. Blood brings oxygen and nutrients, and that’s what repairs damage. That’s why a muscle strain can heal in a few weeks.

Tendons connect muscle to bone, and they don’t get much blood at all. Researchers call tendon a “hypovascular” tissue, which just means low blood supply, per this review in Bone & Joint Research. Less blood means fewer nutrients, less oxygen and a much longer healing time.

Why does age make tendon injuries worse?

Here’s the part most people miss: that blood supply drops even more as you get older. The same review says it “is further diminished with ageing.” A 2023 review in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living also links aging to a slower, less effective repair process.

So think about Neuer’s timeline. First it was an irritation. A few weeks later, it became a partial tear. Same foot, about a month apart. The first injury was the warning sign. The tendon was already hurting, and now it’s coming back to bite him.

Does Neuer’s injury history matter?

It does. His feet have been through a lot. In 2017 he broke a bone in his left foot, then broke it again in training a few months later, and he needed surgery with a plate, per FC Bayern. That one kept him out for most of a season. He’s also had a long list of calf problems over the years.

Every one of those injuries adds up when you’re 40 and your body is already healing slower.

Should Manuel Neuer retire?

Listen, I’m not his doctor. This is my opinion, based on what I know about how the body heals.

His body is telling him something. It’s up to him whether he listens.

Manu, you don’t owe anybody another comeback. You’re the greatest goalkeeper of our generation. So the question isn’t when he’s coming back. It’s whether he should come back at all.

What do you think? Should Neuer call it?

Sources

  1. Bundesliga.com: Bayern Munich confirm Manuel Neuer partial tendon tear
  2. The Star (Reuters): Bayern keeper Neuer suffers partial foot tendon tear
  3. Bone & Joint Research: review on tendon blood supply and healing
  4. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living: tendon healing and aging
  5. FC Bayern: Neuer's repeat metatarsal fracture (2017)
Doc, PharmD, CSN

Written by

Doc, PharmD, CSN

Pharmacist, sports nutritionist, soccer obsessive. Doc breaks down the game with the eye of someone trained to read the evidence.

Free weekly newsletter

Doc's weekly prescription.

The week's best takes from Doc, PharmD, in one email. Once a week. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.